Monday, March 29, 2010

Switching Genres--The Good, The Bad, and The Annoyance.

Today I thought I would give a lecture, I mean a diddy, on switching genres. I find most writers I talk to have one or two loves of genres, the ones they read. And over half of them write in the same genre. Is that bad? No, in fact, I find it welcoming since I read books all the time and think the author should go one way, have a twist with that there, and they don't simply because that isn't their story. It gets your mind ticking into something bigger, not saying better, but bigger to how you might be planning a whole new manuscript based on something that didn't happen. In NO means am I talking about plagerism, as writers I'm hoping the above sentence makes sense, since ideas seem to spark while reading. So that's the good part.

Here's the bad part. If you always read and write in the same genres you'll never never know if your great in something else. Good writers can write anything they say. Well, I think so too. But writers who feel for their genre are brilliant. We all know the ones, those whose words make us believe every word they tell is true like JK Rowling, CS Lewis, Mary Shelley, amd Jane Austen. How can we be like them if we simply just write *good* ? We can't. We have to explore the other side of a whole new genre because even in the end you will learn new skills to story telling, plus maybe even find a new knack. One that will make you great.

The Annoyance. I know, a strong word for a passion. I won't lie, it's tough. I never wanted to read a women's fiction, but I did and guess what? I liked it. I never thought Romance could rock--but guess what? It can. It's also a pain when you don't know which genre is your genre. You'll have to mind your tones when writing in one WIP to another, you will need different Beta targets, and most likely try some agents to query you never thought you would. When you look at it that way, is it really different from the process you're doing right now?

I know I always rant about exploring genres, but I have read too many things lately where I see great potential and really wonder why they won't try another genre out. As always, happy writing! On a softer note, you're all Great already now let's just make the world see it!

17 comments:

  1. I've had success and disappointment when I switched genres. I started writing fantasy, and then tried to write horror. I found that my stories were too flowery and not scary at all! But then I tried Sci fi, and I'm having more success with Sci fi than I did with fantasy! Great post.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm open to reading all genres and I've dabbled in writing a few different ones but I think I'm pretty sure where my heart is. =] That isn't to say that it's set in stone, though. I'm willing to switch it up a little.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm a multi-genre writer. In my opinion, I'm probably strongest in the romance genre, which is probably why even my science fiction and fantasy novels end up with romance in them. Not as the central focus, but there's always a budding romance in there somewhere.

    ReplyDelete
  4. There are only two genres I won't venture into. Other than those, I'm open to reading anything so long as it captures my interest and is written well. :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I read everything but mystery and science fiction regularly...my first novel was literary fiction and my second is paranormal romance...for me it is about the story that comes rather than the genre.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm still early enough along that I haven't settled into a genre. My first novel is urban fantasy, but I am also very drawn to chick lit and women's fiction.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I've always thought the great thing about reading multiple genres is that you don't necessarily have to write IN that genre to benefit. I like to read all sorts of books, but what I love to write is fantasy. When I'm plotting a story though, I'm not afraid to draw on interests in horror, espionage, or any other genre to make my fantasy more unique.

    I agree, all writers would do well to explore multiple genres.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This is GOOD advice. I think it's so easy to burn out if you always read the same genre. Plus sometimes it's scary to read within the same genre that you write while you're writing. I worry about accidentally taking on some of the author's voice.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hey Sara,
    good post and good advice about changing genre. I'm contracted to write crime thrillers (or mystery/suspense thrillers if you prefer)so am recognised as a 'crime writer'. However, those are just the books that are in print or are upcoming. I also write horror, dark fiction, fantasy and humorous crime stories for my own enjoyment, but doubt they'll ever see print. Therein I think the problem lies. Authors break into the field of publication and then get pigeon-holed. Dean Koontz for instance writes horror - or does he? Only one in three books he publishes these days are out and out horror stories. The others tend to be romantic thrillers, or straight thrillers, but you won't find him on the thriller shelf in the bookshop, always on the horror shelf. I think that once you're a name in one genre then it's very difficult to break the trend and write in another. Most authors who have been succesful in transcending genres are those that write under pen names, or are in the 'literary' field where there is more lee-way (think Cormac McCarthy).
    Writing in different genres help me keep fresh, and when I return to my 'normal' crime thriller genre I feel invigorated. It's worth trying something 'totally different' on occasion as it helps kick the muse into action.
    Happy writing
    Matt

    ReplyDelete
  10. Great thoughts here, Sara. Sometimes I worry about being pigeonholed into a small genre, but I see hope here. :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. My greatest success in reading is going to the library and seeing what is on the new release shelf. I can read romantic, mystery, biography, or sometimes I love non-fiction and go for the pschology/spiritual stuff. But too, I love new poets and try to read their work often as I learn my own style and foster this thing I hope to call a craft one day. I've been known to be a story-teller in my poetry writing, but taking from real life is the best genre I can think of. I would love to write an autobiographic novel one day with a real humorous spin on it. Not that my life has been so funny, but looking back on it, I see the humor now where I though pain existed. Amazing how we grow and change. I think it's great to mix it up and try new styles and you may fall into a type of story-telling that you can call your own.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I'd never thought about it as trying it out to see if you rock in it :). You are so right, and now you've got me pondering... I'm the same way--I love fantasy, scifi, and horror, but when I tried women's fiction? Yeah. I love it. Who knew??

    Great food for thought!

    ReplyDelete
  13. That's excellent advice! Fear of failure at another genre is a bit limiting for most of us, especially when we're well published in one genre already, but using a pseudonym to try things out is still a viable option.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I was talking about this subject with another writer buddy earlier today. I agree. I think writers should read everything. I think it makes for better writing.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I love many genres. I believe when we discover our voice the question of genre will be answered.
    Anyone agree or disagree?

    Voice is hard to pin down.

    I look forward to coming back to your blog and reading more.
    Thanks for posting this one. Barb

    www.barbwhitti.blogspot.com
    writing- the ups and downs

    ReplyDelete
  16. Anytime you stretch, you grow, right? You're post about trying different genres is so good. I also like to read in a variety of genres. There's such good writing out there and it's not always in the same place.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Great article. I question the wisdom of switching genres, too. Since I have not established myself as a writer yet, should I worry about which book I promote first? If a well-loved author switches genres, will the fan base be angry and disappointed?

    ReplyDelete

Got something to add or tell? Do it, I don't bite! =D